Is the KBB Instant Cash Offer a scam?

No. It is a lead-generation program working as designed, and the dealer at the end of it may be a perfectly good buyer. Just understand that you were routed and that the number is still subject to an in-person inspection.

Will you match a KBB Instant Cash Offer?

We will beat it by $300 once it has become a real written offer from a dealer who physically inspected your car. The online certificate on its own is a sight-unseen estimate, so there is no verified number to beat yet.

Is the KBB value the same as what my car is worth?

It is an estimate of a range, not a commitment on your specific car. An appraisal is a named buyer committing to a number on the vehicle in front of them — those are different things.

The $300 Best-Offer Guarantee

Sell My Car STL vs. KBB Instant Cash Offer.

The thing most sellers miss: Kelley Blue Book does not buy cars. That offer is a referral to a dealership — and we are what the referral leads to.

Get My Two Offers

4.8 on GoogleFree & no obligationSt. Louis, MO

Sell My Car STL vs. KBB Instant Cash Offer — two offers for your car

The honest rundown

How the KBB Instant Cash Offer actually works

You enter your car's details on Kelley Blue Book and receive an Instant Cash Offer with a certificate. What has happened behind the scenes is a lead hand-off: the offer is underwritten and honored by a <em>participating dealership</em> near you, which then inspects the car and finalizes the number. KBB is the brand on the certificate, not the buyer of your car.

This is not a scam — it is a lead-generation program working exactly as designed, and the dealership at the end of it may well be a good buyer. But it is worth knowing that you are being routed, that the routing is paid for, and that the number on the certificate is subject to the same in-person revision any sight-unseen quote is.

Paperwork and keys on a desk during a car sale

Side by side

The comparison, in plain rows

KBB Instant Cash OfferSell My Car STL

Who actually buys the carA participating dealership — not KBBWe do; the appraiser and the buyer are the same company

Offers you seeOne, generated before anyone saw the carTwo, after a physical appraisal

Number stabilityRevised at the dealership inspectionFirm once we have appraised it

Who chose your buyerThe referral programYou did

Retail upsideNoneProfit sharing pays a second check at retail

Qualifies for our $300 beatOnly after the dealer inspects and writes it—

Fair is fair

Where the KBB route honestly wins

It is a useful piece of market research, and it is free. If you want a rough sense of your car's wholesale neighborhood before talking to anyone, the estimate is a reasonable starting anchor — Kelley Blue Book has decades of data behind it.

And if the participating dealer inspects your car and writes you a number that beats both of ours, that is a good sale and you should take it. That written, inspected offer is also precisely what qualifies for our $300 guarantee, so running the KBB route first costs you nothing.

Our side of the ledger

Where we win

One fewer party in the transaction: the company that appraises your car is the company that writes the check.
Two offers rather than one, including a profit-sharing option that targets retail instead of wholesale.
No sight-unseen anchor to be negotiated down from — we look at the car and then commit.
If the referred dealer's inspected offer is higher, we pay $300 over it.

The honest verdict

Use the KBB number as a reference point, not as an offer. Then get a real appraisal from a company that buys cars directly, and compare two actual numbers against the estimate rather than one estimate against itself.

Get both of our numbers

Don't take our word for it — ask the robots

An honest comparison has nothing to hide from a second opinion.

FAQ

KBB Instant Cash Offer vs. us: quick answers

No. The Instant Cash Offer is honored by a participating dealership that inspects the car and finalizes the number. KBB is the brand on the certificate, not the purchaser.

Keep digging

More honest homework

Compare

vs. CarMax

The national giant, compared honestly

Read the comparison

Compare

vs. Dealer Trade-In

The tax-credit myth, debunked with math

Read the comparison

Paperwork

How to Sell a Car in St. Louis

Read the guide

Car keys on a desk beside a tax statement

Getting the most money

Personal Property Tax and the Best Month to Sell Your Car

Read the guide

Selling near you:Ballwin, MO O'Fallon, MO All areas we serve

Sell or Trade Your Car in St. Louis, MO

Get an Instant Cash Offer for Your Car in St. Louis

Find out how much your car is worth with our free online tool. Get an instant cash offer or trade-in value in minutes and sell your car hassle-free at Sell My Car STL in St. Louis, MO.

Learn more about our trade valuations

Plate Number

Registered State