Selling a Car With Body or Accident Damage in St. Louis
Body damage splits into two very different cars: one that is cosmetically hurt and one that is structurally hurt. The gap between them is most of the value.
Get My Two OffersCosmetic · we buy it as it sits No repairs required4.8 Ballwin (294 Google reviews) 4.9 O'Fallon (95 Google reviews)
The math
Cosmetic damage and structural damage are different markets
A crumpled door skin, a scraped bumper cover and a deer-strike front end are cosmetic problems on a car that is otherwise fine. They look expensive and they appraise far better than they look, because the frame, drivetrain and safety structure are untouched. Deer strikes in particular are a Missouri constant and an entirely normal thing for us to buy.
Structural damage is a different car. Once the unibody, frame rails or suspension pickup points are involved, the repair cost climbs fast and the car's ceiling drops permanently even after a correct repair. That is the car where selling as-is tends to beat repairing by the widest margin, because you are never getting the repair money back.
The decision almost always comes down to one question: has an insurer already been involved? If a claim is open and the payout plus the salvage value exceeds what anyone will pay you for the intact car, take the insurance route. If you are self-funding the repair out of pocket on a car you planned to sell anyway, you are spending your own money to raise someone else's buying price.
How the offer gets built
How damage gets appraised
Cosmetic versus structural is the first and biggest fork, and we will tell you plainly which one we think you have.
Airbag deployment moves the number significantly — the restraint system is expensive and its replacement is not optional.
A half-finished repair is usually worth less than no repair at all, because the next shop has to undo it first.
A clean title on a damaged car is worth protecting. Once it becomes a salvage or rebuilt title the market narrows sharply.
Drivable or not changes the number, same as any other fault.
Straight talk
When we are not your best option
If your insurer has declared it a total loss, take the settlement. A total-loss payout is based on the car's pre-accident value and will almost always beat what any buyer pays for the wreck. And if the damage is light, cheap to fix, and the car is otherwise clean and desirable, a proper repair before a private sale can genuinely pay — that is the one damage scenario where fixing first wins.
Two offers, one visit
You still get both numbers
Instant Cash Offer
A firm number, good for 7 days, with the fault priced at our repair cost rather than a retail shop's estimate.
How the cash offer worksProfit-Sharing
A reserve check up front, then a second check for your share once we have sorted the car out and sold it at retail.
How profit sharing pays more
Sell or Trade Your Car in St. Louis, MO
Get an Instant Cash Offer for Your Car in St. Louis
Find out how much your car is worth with our free online tool. Get an instant cash offer or trade-in value in minutes and sell your car hassle-free at Sell My Car STL in St. Louis, MO.
Learn more about our trade valuations